• About
  • Books
  • One Word
  • Cousin Camp
  • Speaking
  • Audio
  • Blog
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter
    • YouTube
Susan Alexander Yates

Susan Alexander Yates

Wisdom for Every Season

  • Character
  • Faith
  • Family
  • Seasons
  • Marriage
  • Parenting
  • Cousin Camp
  • Ask Susan

Mothers-in-Law and Daughters-in-Law: Women Share Their Hearts

by Susan Alexander Yates

Recently I posted a blog about being a mother–in-law (click here to read). It generated a lot of response, so I decided to probe a little deeper and sent a questionnaire to a number of friends, both mothers and daughters. I was after honesty and I got it!

I asked 2 questions and received a variety of answers:

If you are the mother-in-law: What do you wish your daughter-in-law knew about you? 

  • I wish she knew how badly I want a relationship with her and that I know I mess up sometimes.
  • I wish she knew how frightened I am that she won’t love or accept me and I will be locked out of a full relationship with her, my son, and grandchildren to come.
  • Sometimes I worry that our relationship will be a formality and not true love.
  • It can be hard for me when they spend most of their spare time with her family. It makes me feel unwanted.
  • Sometimes I don’t feel appreciated for all that I do. A thank you note, a text, an email would be wonderful. (And I wish she’d teach their kids to do this as well.)
  • I wish she’d call me simply to say, “How are you and how can I be praying for you?”
  • I would love it if she initiated time with me.

If you are a daughter-in-law: What do you wish your mother-in-law knew about you?

  • That I felt pressured by her to leave my job when I had our first baby. Her strong views made me feel like she didn’t value what I felt in giving up my job.
  • I want to trust that she will keep confidences that I share with her and not tell someone else.
  • I want her to want to know me in adulthood and not always talk about her son when he was small but also about his life and mine now.
  • I wish she knew how much I want a good relationship with her. I wish she’d call me by my name.
  • I wish she would let me “be me” with my own history and not expect me to be like her.
  • I wish she knew I am not competing with her. How she and I do things may be different but I am not competing.
  • I need her appreciation and encouragement.
  • I wish she’d let me help her and do things for her.

These are just a few of the responses, but what was surprising to me was how similar many of the responses were.

What I see is that both mothers-in-law and daughters-in-law long for good relationships.

With some family dysfunction this may not be possible or it may take a very long time but generally speaking it is the desire on both sides.

Unfortunately our culture assumes that this relationship is difficult, contentious and most often unpleasant. Pointed jokes produce laughter but also cause pain and create expectations for a difficult relationship. Expectations which may be false.

What if we understood that we are both sinful people in need of forgiveness? It’s not because we are in-laws that we sometimes don’t get along. It’s because we are humans.  

What if we began to speak about this relationship in positive terms?

What if instead of reacting we began to grant grace?

A 32 year-old friend of mine put it this way:

I found the hardest hurdle for me was going from having a mother-in-law who felt more of “the other” to having a second mother. It took several years but somewhere along the line she stopped being my “in-law” and started to just be my family. I think the best thing you can do to have a healthy relationship with your mother-in-law is to really take the ‘what’s yours is mine’ part of marriage seriously and to really love her like you love your own mother. She is yours and that is precious. And from there we can remember that family doesn’t always agree or get along but they always love each other, fight for each other, and take care of each other with a love like none other.

Whatever your relationship is like, it’s most important to remember that God knows both of you intimately.

He knows our every thought (Psalm 139). He loves each of us unconditionally. He desires for our relationship with our in-law to be one of love and acceptance. He will use us to sharpen each other. He is in the process of growing both of us up into the women He has created us to be (Philippians 1:6). It will take time. We are impatient. He is not. Be encouraged!

“Nothing is impossible for Him.”
Luke 1:37


Join my friends at Club31Women and Kindred Grace for more on mother-in-law/daughter-in-law relationships!

Don’t miss my post, 10 Things I’d Love for My Daughter-in-Law to Know About Me.

Find the rest of the series by following the links below:

How to Love Your Mother-in-Law and Daughter-in-Law at Club31Women

How to Love Your In-Laws at Kindred Grace

Save this post on Pinterest:

Share240
Pin27
Tweet
Email
Print
267Shares
Share240
Share
Pin27
Text
267Shares

You may also enjoy...

Family, In-Laws
May 13, 2020 · 7 Comments

« My Mother’s Day Gift to You: Help & Hope!
Ask Susan: How to Handle Conflict and Expectations in Marriage »

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments

  1. Ritha says

    February 1, 2021 at 12:16 pm

    My son lives in our flat rent free. My d-in-law says he should be ashamed of himself . We do not believe in taking rent from our kids. But they paid us a nominal rent for a few years which we put in a separate account for her child’s education ! Now she complains she has no control over this account . Why does she expect “control” over an amount she paid (half) as “rent”?

    Reply
  2. Pamela says

    October 10, 2020 at 12:50 am

    I’ve been praying for others who understand my feelings about being an MIL. It is nice to find this blog. Pam

    Reply
    • susan yates says

      October 20, 2020 at 8:03 pm

      Thanks for writing Pam! It’s so encouraging to hear from readers.
      Bless you!
      Susan

      Reply
      • RockyBreeze says

        November 15, 2020 at 5:15 pm

        My mil tried to usurp her own granddaughters inheritance from her deceased parent. She demanded her son and other dil quit their jobs and move out of town to take care of her for 3 months while was recovering from an injury (she had family available in the same city). She says mean things about her dila that are not the same race as herself. She puts herself into and above her adult children and even grandchildren’s marriages. She gets jealous if her kids spend too much time with their own children.

        Reply
        • susan yates says

          November 18, 2020 at 7:46 pm

          I am so sorry for your situation Rocky. I am praying for the wisdom of James 1:5 for you this evening. I think it would be helpful if you could get some guidance from a Pastor or counselor in how to address this situation.
          Bless you.
          Susan

          Reply
  3. Gretchen Louise says

    April 11, 2018 at 4:28 pm

    Thank you so much for sharing from your heart and the hearts of these mothers-in-law and daughters-in-law. I’m so grateful for the reminder to put expectations aside, and simply to grant grace. Thank you.

    Reply
    • susan says

      April 15, 2018 at 9:00 pm

      Thanks so much Gretchen!
      You are such an encourager!
      Blessings, Susan

      Reply

Hello, I’m Susan.

Susan Alexander Yates

I’m a wife (of more than 50 years), mom to five children (including a set of twins), and grandmother to 21 (including a set of quadruplets!). My favorite time of the year is when all my kids and grandkids are together for a week of “cousins and family camp” in the foothills of the Shenandoah Mountains of Virginia.

Read more…

Recent Posts

  • 10 Questions to Ask Yourself When You Need to Make a Hard Decision
  • Celebrate! Your Recipe for a One-Day Summer Gratitude Extravaganza
  • Feeling Afraid? Remembering God’s Faithfulness Will Help
  • Our Weeping, Suffering Savior: Why This Matters to Me & You
  • How God’s Creation Comforts and Restores Me

One Word

One Word: Sufficient

Featured Book

Cousin Camp

Cousin Camp
Buy This Book Online
30% Off
Buy from Amazon
Buy from Barnes and Noble
Buy from Christian Book Distributor
Buy from Lifeway
Buy from Books-A-Million
Buy from GoodReads
Cousin Camp
Buy now!

Barbara & Susan’s Guide to the Empty Nest: Discovering New Purpose, Passion & Your Next Great Adventure

Barbara & Susan’s Guide to the Empty Nest: Discovering New Purpose, Passion & Your Next Great Adventure
Buy This Book Online
Buy from Amazon
Buy from Amazon Kindle
Barbara & Susan’s Guide to the Empty Nest: Discovering New Purpose, Passion & Your Next Great Adventure
Buy now!
  • Certainty In Christ
  • Subscribe
  • Contact
  • Media Kit
  • Privacy Policy
  • Site Index

Search

Popular

  • Our Best Advice for Your Marriage: What We’ve…
  • What’s the big deal about a donkey?
  • How Do You Do It? (Questions for a Mom of Quads)

One Word: Saves One Verse: “The saying is tr One Word:  Saves
 
One Verse:

“The saying is trustworthy and deserving of full acceptance, that Christ Jesus came into the world to save sinners, of whom I am the foremost." 1 Timothy 1:15
 
One Thought:

Father, I am a sinner. Thank you for saving me once and for all. Help ______ to come to realize that you want to save him (or her) as well. Your nature is to save. Your love compels it. You cannot help it. You sent Jesus to redeem each one of us.
On a walk the other day I noticed beautiful Iris p On a walk the other day I noticed beautiful Iris plants beginning to bloom. They were surrounded by plants I didn't recognized except that I know some were weeds. 

This metaphor came to mind: ‘Our lives have both beauty and weeds mixed together. It’s easy to focus on the weeds (illnesses, hurtful relationships, a difficult decision, a longing unfulfilled), however it’s healthier to focus on the beauty. 

And if we don’t know what is a weed or a possible plant God knows. He will reveal them to us when we need to know and what we discover may surprise us. It helps to remember that HE is in the midst of whatever we are experiencing.
I have a gift for you this week! In my blog, I'm s I have a gift for you this week! In my blog, I'm sharing 10 questions to ask yourself when you're trying to make a hard decision. ⁣
⁣
We all struggle with decision-making! Especially when it's not a clear moral choice between right and wrong.⁣
⁣
Some years ago, my pastor husband John came up with this list of 10 questions to help make decisions. I'm sharing them on the blog, and my friend, artist Jess Blanchard @jessblanchardstudio turned them into a gorgeous bookmark you can download for free.⁣
⁣
You might want to laminate it and keep it in your Bible. I hope it's a blessing to you.⁣
⁣
Read the blog and download the bookmark -- link in bio, or go to susanalexanderyates.com/blog
One Word: Holds One Verse: “Nevertheless, I One Word:  Holds
 
One Verse:

“Nevertheless, I am continually with you; you hold my right hand." Psalm 73:23
 
One Thought:

Dear God, help me to remember all day today that you are holding my hand. You never let go.
I just got back from a quick trip to Chicago with I just got back from a quick trip to Chicago with two friends (Barbara Rainey and Joanne Thompson) to hear poet Malcolm Guite @uitemalcolm3774 lecture and to visit the Lilias Trotter collection at Wheaton College. We got to read her journals and hold her precious art. She was an artist in the late 1800’s who gave up a promising career to go to Algeria for the next 20 years to minister to poor women. @laurawatershinson has produced a movie about her called Many Beautiful Things. (It's wonderful! Look it up if you haven't seen it.) #manybeautifulthingsmovie 

We were inspired by both of these people. It was wonderfully refreshing to get out of our own worlds and away from ”our stuff” and focus on something completely “other!” We all need to do this😊
This verse from Psalm 105 speaks to me. How easy i This verse from Psalm 105 speaks to me. How easy it is to forget -- rather than to remember -- what He has done. Or to focus on all the crises around me. It’s easy to lose perspective on life and on what God is doing. ⁣
⁣
Setting aside a specific day this summer for celebrating God's faithfulness will restore our PERSPECTIVE.⁣
⁣
I'm sharing ideas in my blog you might want to use to put together a summer gratitude extravaganza of your own!  I hope you'll check it out.⁣
⁣
Link in bio, or go to susanalexanderyates.com/blog⁣
⁣
Let us remember the wonders He has done!
One Word: Mighty One Verse: “O Lord God of h One Word:  Mighty
 
One Verse:

“O Lord God of hosts, who is mighty as you are, O Lord, with your faithfulness all around you?" Psalm 89:9
 
One Thought:

Father, too often I forget that you are mighty. I unknowingly assign to you my own weakness without even realizing it. Forgive me. I want to dwell on your mighty power today. Your might levels mountains, raises seas, heals diseases, changes hearts and creates a complex human body. When I focus on your might my perspective is restored.
@jodie_berndt’s new book, Praying the Scriptures @jodie_berndt’s new book, Praying the Scriptures for your Marriage, is the #1 book I would recommend on marriage.

Written with her husband Robbie, it’s honest, funny and very practical. Her down to earth style will make you feel normal with the challenges we all face in marriage, but she doesn’t leave us there. She provides us with tips for communication, relevant scriptures, and samples of specific prayers to pray for your marriage. Get a copy for yourself and several for wedding gifts or anniversary presents!

We’ve been married 53 years and this book is so good for us!

Thank you Jodie!
A craft table at the farm with some of our budding A craft table at the farm with some of our budding artists (grandchildren). ⁣
⁣
I have an idea for you: Let's put on our calendars now a SUMMER CELEBRATION DAY!⁣
⁣
The purpose? To set aside one whole day to recount God’s faithfulness with thanksgiving. This simple act can lead to a day of praise and worship and a closeness with others as we share His goodness together.⁣
⁣
There are so many ways you can do this! On your own, on a day-long (or hour-long) retreat. With your immediate or extended family. With church friends. ⁣
⁣
Out in a park or inside on a rainy day. With a craft table like ours or with music or food or sports -- or all of the above!⁣
⁣
I'm sharing lots of ideas in this week's blog: Celebrate! Your Recipe for a One-Day Summer Gratitude Extravaganza  Link in bio or go to susanalexanderyates.com/blog⁣
⁣
I hope you'll plan something and I'd love to hear what you do!

Copyright © 2023 · Susan Alexander Yates · All Rights Reserved
Calligraphy by Jessica Blanchard · Paintings by Christen Yates
Blog and Ask Susan Photo by Natalie Puls Photography · Books Photo by Cambria Elizabeth

267Shares
267Shares
We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.OkayPrivacy Policy